Comments on: Best Southern Potato Salad Recipe (With Secret Ingredient!) https://www.mrshappyhomemaker.com/best-ever-potato-salad/ Where Old Fashioned and Modern Day Collide Mon, 14 Oct 2024 20:14:22 +0000 hourly 1 By: Crystal https://www.mrshappyhomemaker.com/best-ever-potato-salad/#comment-181484 https://mrshappyhomemaker64452.e.wpstage.net/?p=11974#comment-181484 In reply to Patty.

That’s just the way I was taught to do it

]]> By: Patty https://www.mrshappyhomemaker.com/best-ever-potato-salad/#comment-178356 https://mrshappyhomemaker64452.e.wpstage.net/?p=11974#comment-178356 Crystal why leave potatoes whole when cooking instead of dicing?

]]> By: Sandie https://www.mrshappyhomemaker.com/best-ever-potato-salad/#comment-177942 https://mrshappyhomemaker64452.e.wpstage.net/?p=11974#comment-177942 5 stars
I make mine almost identical to this with one exception.  I put a dash of sugar in it to kick the bitterness of the mustard.

]]> By: Lisa Picklesimer https://www.mrshappyhomemaker.com/best-ever-potato-salad/#comment-173575 https://mrshappyhomemaker64452.e.wpstage.net/?p=11974#comment-173575 Same as my family recipe. We always used little green onions. Lots of them. I agree has to be dill pickles.

]]> By: Crystal https://www.mrshappyhomemaker.com/best-ever-potato-salad/#comment-100003 https://mrshappyhomemaker64452.e.wpstage.net/?p=11974#comment-100003 In reply to Sara.

I’m so glad that you enjoyed it! Thank you so much for coming back and leaving a comment!

]]> By: Sara https://www.mrshappyhomemaker.com/best-ever-potato-salad/#comment-99963 https://mrshappyhomemaker64452.e.wpstage.net/?p=11974#comment-99963 I’m so glad I found this recipe!!! My first time making potato salad, and it turned out great!!! So yummy!!!!!

]]> By: Danita https://www.mrshappyhomemaker.com/best-ever-potato-salad/#comment-80887 https://mrshappyhomemaker64452.e.wpstage.net/?p=11974#comment-80887 I just made your recipe for a Christmas potluck at my husband’s work tomorrow!! First time I have ever made potato salad. Omg it is soooo good, I’m sure it will get a lot of compliments!!

]]> By: Crystal https://www.mrshappyhomemaker.com/best-ever-potato-salad/#comment-77396 https://mrshappyhomemaker64452.e.wpstage.net/?p=11974#comment-77396 In reply to Michelle.

About 6 servings, maybe 8 depending on how much everyone is eating.

]]> By: Crystal https://www.mrshappyhomemaker.com/best-ever-potato-salad/#comment-77389 https://mrshappyhomemaker64452.e.wpstage.net/?p=11974#comment-77389 In reply to Happy Mamma.

I just love this comment so much! I’m sorry you’re mom passed so young – losing those we love is never easy. I think it’s so cool that y’all made the potato salad to help remember her by though, what I wonderful idea. Thank you so much for commenting! The potato salad is definitely a favorite of ours as well, and you’re right – that pickle juice makes it!

]]> By: Happy Mamma https://www.mrshappyhomemaker.com/best-ever-potato-salad/#comment-76747 https://mrshappyhomemaker64452.e.wpstage.net/?p=11974#comment-76747 My mom always made this potato salad and it was a favorite! She passed away from cancer at age 57 this April and she requested that this be served at her funeral–and my sister and I had to make it because we were the only ones who would get it right:-) The only thing missing from your version is dill weed. She was a “handful of this, pinch of that” kind of cook, so when we made it for the funeral that’s how we did it! It’s how she taught us. When I saw your video I just was looking at each ingredient going in and when you had it all mixed up with no pickle juice I thought you had it all wrong! But then you saved yourself:-) Most of the time growing up we used sour cream instead of the mayo, and eventually started doing half and half. Too much mayo is a little too rich, but the sour cream tones it down, and just straight sour cream isn’t quite as flavorful. I never comment on these things, but I had to this time!

]]> By: Michelle https://www.mrshappyhomemaker.com/best-ever-potato-salad/#comment-70149 https://mrshappyhomemaker64452.e.wpstage.net/?p=11974#comment-70149 How many does this feed?

]]> By: JD Rogers https://www.mrshappyhomemaker.com/best-ever-potato-salad/#comment-63356 https://mrshappyhomemaker64452.e.wpstage.net/?p=11974#comment-63356 How many will this feed?

]]>