Comments on: Great Grandma’s Coconut Custard Pie https://www.mrshappyhomemaker.com/coconut-custard-pie-best-ever/ Where Old Fashioned and Modern Day Collide Thu, 25 Jan 2024 18:39:56 +0000 hourly 1 By: Angelique https://www.mrshappyhomemaker.com/coconut-custard-pie-best-ever/#comment-182219 http://thepixelista.com/crystal-test/2011/03/coconut-custard-pie-best-ever/#comment-182219 In reply to tom | tall clover farm.

Just so you know, 13 years after your post, I’ve run across it and am Amused.
As hostile as the internet can be, it’s important to know that YOUR contribution here mattered neyo d what you were expecting.
Thanks for that.

]]> By: Alea Vorillas https://www.mrshappyhomemaker.com/coconut-custard-pie-best-ever/#comment-182085 http://thepixelista.com/crystal-test/2011/03/coconut-custard-pie-best-ever/#comment-182085 5 stars
Cut the amount of sugar in half and this pie is perfect.  

]]> By: Crystal https://www.mrshappyhomemaker.com/coconut-custard-pie-best-ever/#comment-106196 http://thepixelista.com/crystal-test/2011/03/coconut-custard-pie-best-ever/#comment-106196 In reply to AJ Noyes.

Maybe a deep dish!

]]> By: AJ Noyes https://www.mrshappyhomemaker.com/coconut-custard-pie-best-ever/#comment-105798 http://thepixelista.com/crystal-test/2011/03/coconut-custard-pie-best-ever/#comment-105798 Would it work to put all filling in one crust?

]]> By: Crystal https://www.mrshappyhomemaker.com/coconut-custard-pie-best-ever/#comment-91608 http://thepixelista.com/crystal-test/2011/03/coconut-custard-pie-best-ever/#comment-91608 In reply to Patrick Jones.

I’m so glad that you love it!!

]]> By: Patrick Jones https://www.mrshappyhomemaker.com/coconut-custard-pie-best-ever/#comment-90989 http://thepixelista.com/crystal-test/2011/03/coconut-custard-pie-best-ever/#comment-90989 In reply to Crystal.

This is what I have been searching for. Just made it and it is divine! Love it!

]]> By: Maureen https://www.mrshappyhomemaker.com/coconut-custard-pie-best-ever/#comment-82530 http://thepixelista.com/crystal-test/2011/03/coconut-custard-pie-best-ever/#comment-82530 3 stars
Too sweet! I’ll give this another try, but with one cup of sugar and not two. I also think the texture might benefit from a couple tablespoons of flour.

]]> By: Crystal https://www.mrshappyhomemaker.com/coconut-custard-pie-best-ever/#comment-80175 http://thepixelista.com/crystal-test/2011/03/coconut-custard-pie-best-ever/#comment-80175 In reply to Anndra Martinelli.

Large

]]> By: Crystal https://www.mrshappyhomemaker.com/coconut-custard-pie-best-ever/#comment-80174 http://thepixelista.com/crystal-test/2011/03/coconut-custard-pie-best-ever/#comment-80174 In reply to Dee.

Doubling is fine!

]]> By: Crystal https://www.mrshappyhomemaker.com/coconut-custard-pie-best-ever/#comment-80172 http://thepixelista.com/crystal-test/2011/03/coconut-custard-pie-best-ever/#comment-80172 In reply to Arwen Evenstar.

I think that you could and bake it as normal, but I’d give a good spray of nonstick cooking spray beforehand.

]]> By: Arwen Evenstar https://www.mrshappyhomemaker.com/coconut-custard-pie-best-ever/#comment-80013 http://thepixelista.com/crystal-test/2011/03/coconut-custard-pie-best-ever/#comment-80013 I am getting ready to make this pie as well, because it seems like it may be the same pie my great-grandmother used to make as well.  I wish I was older and wiser before she passed so that I could get some of these recipes.  My question is this-Do you think I could make this as a No Crust pie, or do I definitely have to have a crust?  Also, would it possible affect baking time?  Thanks so much, and Happy Thanksgiving to you!

]]> By: Dee https://www.mrshappyhomemaker.com/coconut-custard-pie-best-ever/#comment-79987 http://thepixelista.com/crystal-test/2011/03/coconut-custard-pie-best-ever/#comment-79987 Can I double this for 4 pies or make 2 separate batches?

]]>